Comparable diameter resulted in larger leaf area and denser foliage in the park trees than in street trees: A study on Norway maples of Karlsruhe city, Germany

The leaf area of trees is the main surface of energy and matter exchange between the plant canopy and the atmosphere. A better understanding of canopy structure variations in cities is a prerequisite to evaluating leaf area and ecosystem services. We selected 58 single-standing and healthy Norway maple trees (Acer platanoides L.), equally distributed between the park and street at the same tree size for canopy structure and leaf area measurements. The canopy structures of street trees and park trees were different. Street trees had significantly higher dieback (p < 0.01), crown damage (p < 0.01), and branch-free bole length (p < 0.001) than park trees. Even though we sampled trees with similar diameters, park tree crowns tended to be healthier and denser than street trees. The crown volume, crown projection area (CPA), light availability (Crown Light Exposure or CLE), and foliage density were lower in street trees than in park trees. The average foliage density of street trees is 20 % lower than park trees. All the above differences in crown volume and foliage density lead to a significantly lower leaf area in street trees. The total leaf area of a single street tree was only 83 m² on average, compared to 186 m² among park trees. We demonstrated that crown volume and growing habitats (i.e., park or street) are important explanatory variables for leaf area. We conclude that a precise and site-specific evaluation of leaf areas is a prerequisite for accuracy in quantifying ecosystem services from urban trees.