We previously showed that the oxidant peroxynitrite (ONOO-) was strongly mutagenic in the supF shuttle vector pSP189 replicated in bacteria or human cells. Qualitative characteristics of the mutational spectra induced by ONOO- differed significantly from those reportedly caused by hydroxyl radical (OH.) in other experimental systems but showed similarities to spectra reportedly produced by singlet oxygen (1O2). The molecular mechanisms of ONOO--mediated DNA damage are unknown. The objective of the present set of experiments was to characterize mutational effects induced in the supF gene of pSP189 by OH* and 1O2 to permit direct comparison with mutational spectra induced by ONOO- in this system. Base substitutions were the major form of mutation induced in plasmids replicated in human (AD293) cells by ONOO- (84%) and 1O2 (71%), whereas OH* induced fewer of them (49%). In plasmids replicated in bacteria (Escherichia coli MBL50), frequencies of base substitutions induced by the three treatments were similar. G:C-to-T:A transversions were the most common form of base substitution induced by ONOO- (75% and 67%, respectively, in AD293- and MBL50-replicated plasmids) and 1O2 (68% and 71%); they were induced at lower frequencies by OH. (51% and 47%). G:C-to-C:G transversions or G:C-to-A:T transitions were induced at almost equal frequencies by both ONOO- and 1O2, whereas OH* induced these mutations at different frequencies in the AD293 system. Collectively, our results confirm that in several important respects mutational spectra induced by ONOO- have greater similarity to spectra induced by 1O2 than to those induced by OH* and suggest that genotoxic derivatives of ONOO- are likely to include species that have DNA-damaging properties resembling those of 1O2 in selectivity for guanine but not identical in sequence specificity.