We describe two patients with defibrillation failure of implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) resulting from large left pneumothoraxes following subclavian vein puncture during the implantation. Following pneumothorax drainage, low defibrillation thresholds (DFTs) were attained without further manipulations. The absence of other signs and symptoms of pneumothorax and the presence of satisfactory pacing function during the procedure, resulted in a significant delay in diagnosis. Pneumothorax should be included in the differential diagnosis when unexpected high DFTs are found during ICD implantation or predischarge testing. This complication is avoidable by a different surgical approach, cephalic vein cutdown.