Use of cementless acetabular cups, which are slightly larger than the reamed acetabulum, can provide press-fit stability without screws; however, the ideal cup geometry to maximize stability is not clear. Acetabular strain distribution, deformation, and implant stability were studied using an axisymmetric finite-element model, and mechanical stability was assessed by testing lever-out and extraction forces required to displace different cup geometries from foam bones. The implants tested included four nonhemispheric cup geometries and 1- and 2-mm oversized hemispheric geometries. A nonhemispheric cup that provides a gradual transition from a hemisphere at the dome to a larger peripheral dimension appears to maximize peripheral strains and implant stability without increasing overall acetabular deformation as much as a larger oversized hemispheric cup.