Aqueous-phase electrocatalytic hydrogenation of benzaldehyde on Cu leads not only to benzyl alcohol (the carbonyl hydrogenation product), but Cu also catalyzes carbon-carbon coupling to hydrobenzoin. In the absence of an organic substrate, H2 evolution proceeds via the Volmer-Tafel mechanism on Cu/C, with the Tafel step being rate-determining. In the presence of benzaldehyde, the catalyst surface is primarily covered with the organic substrate, while H* coverage is low. Mechanistically, the first H addition to the carbonyl O of an adsorbed benzaldehyde molecule leads to a surface-bound hydroxy intermediate. The hydroxy intermediate then undergoes a second and rate-determining H addition to its α-C to form benzyl alcohol. The H additions occur predominantly via the proton-coupled electron transfer mechanism. In a parallel reaction, the radical α-C of the hydroxy intermediate attacks the electrophilic carbonyl C of a physisorbed benzaldehyde molecule to form the C-C bond, which is rate-determining. The C-C coupling is accompanied by the protonation of the formed alkoxy radical intermediate, coupled with electron transfer from the surface of Cu, to form hydrobenzoin.