Psychiatric mental health nurse practitioners experiencing therapeutic alliance while using tele-mental health: A phenomenological study

Abstract

Background: Psychiatric mental health nurse practitioners have rapidly adopted and implemented tele-mental health in their practice; however it is unclear how this modality of care affects the experiential quality of therapeutic alliance, simply defined as the interpersonal working bond between provider and patient.

Objective: This study is the first to explore how psychiatric mental health nurse practitioners experience therapeutic alliance while using tele-mental health.

Design: Husserlian phenomenological qualitative study.

Participants: A purposive, convenience sample of 17 American psychiatric mental health nurse practitioners who engaged in tele-mental health care were recruited online and interviewed.

Methods: Phenomenological interview transcripts recorded and later thematically coded in the qualitative software MaxQDA.

Results: From 1426 individual codes, five major themes and 16 subthemes were discovered. Overall, themes illuminated that psychiatric mental health nurse practitioners could build therapeutic alliance over tele-mental health using inherent interpersonal skills that had to be adapted to the technology. Adaptions included working with patient environmental factors, individual patient considerations, provider ambivalence, and technological observation shifting awareness and communication patterns.

Conclusions: When adapting for the tele-mental health environment, psychiatric mental health nurse practitioners experienced building and sustaining therapeutic alliance with most patients. Unparalleled aspects of tele-mental health allowed for a fuller clinical picture and logistical convenience to see patients more often with ease for both the provider and patient. However, experiential aspects of therapeutic alliance created during in-person care could not be replaced with tele-mental health. In conclusion, participants concluded that a hybrid care model would enhance therapeutic alliance for most patients.

Keywords: Advanced practice nursing; Nurse-patient relations; Qualitative research; Telehealth; Therapeutic alliance.