Recombination rate variation shapes genomic variability of phylogeographic structure in a widespread North American songbird (Aves: Certhia americana)

Abstract

The nonrandom distribution of chromosomal characteristics and functional elements-genomic architecture-impacts the relative strengths and impacts of population genetic processes across the genome. Due to this relationship, genomic architecture has the potential to shape variation in population genetic structure across the genome. Population genetic structure has been shown to vary across the genome in a variety of taxa, but this body of work has largely focused on pairwise population genomic comparisons between closely related taxa. Here, we used whole genome sequencing of seven phylogeographically structured populations of a North American songbird, the Brown Creeper (Certhia americana), to determine the impacts of genomic architecture on phylogeographic structure variation across the genome. Using multiple methods to infer phylogeographic structure-ordination, clustering, and phylogenetic methods-we found that recombination rate variation explained a large proportion of phylogeographic structure variation. Genomic regions with low recombination showed phylogeographic structure consistent with the genome-wide pattern. In regions with high recombination, we found strong phylogeographic structure, but with discordant patterns relative to the genome-wide pattern. In regions with high recombination rate, we found that populations with small effective population sizes evolve relatively more rapidly than larger populations, leading to discordant signatures of phylogeographic structure. These results suggest that the interplay between recombination rate variation and effective population sizes shape the relative impacts of selection and genetic drift in different parts of the genome. Overall, the combined interactions of population genetic processes, genomic architecture, and effective population sizes shape patterns of variability in phylogeographic structure across the genome of the Brown Creeper.

Keywords: Demography; Genetic architecture; Phylogeography; Population genomics.