Metal nanocrystals (NCs) produced by colloidal synthesis have a variety of structural features, such as different planes, edges, and defects. Even from the best colloidal syntheses, these characteristics are distributed differently in each NC. This inherent heterogeneity can play a significant role in the properties displayed by NCs. This manuscript reports the use of electrochemistry to synthesize Au NCs in a system evaluated to track individual NC growth trajectories as a first step toward rapid identification of NCs with different structural features. Au nanocubes were prepared colloidally and deposited onto a glassy carbon electrode using either electrospray or an airbrush, resulting in well-spaced Au nanocubes. The Au nanocubes then served as seeds as gold salt was reduced to deposit metal at constant potential. Deposition at constant potential facilitates overgrowth on the Au nanocubes to achieve new NC shapes. The effects of applied potential, deposition time, precursor concentration, and capping agents on NC shape evolution were studied. The outcomes are correlated to results from traditional colloidal syntheses, providing a bridge between the two synthetic strategies. Moreover, scanning electron microscopy was used to image the same NCs before and after deposition, linking individual seed features to differences in deposition. This ability is anticipated to enable tracking of individual growth trajectories of NCs to elucidate sources of heterogeneity in NC syntheses.