Adult-type diffuse gliomas are the most prevalent type of malignant adult brain tumors. Intratumoral heterogeneity can hinder accurate diagnosis and subsequent treatment. This case report documents a tumor with intratumoral heterogeneity, both histologically and by methylation analysis, located within the left cerebral hemisphere of a 29-year-old female. She presented after a witnessed generalized tonic clonic seizure at home. Two years prior she had a witnessed seizure; however, no brain imaging was done at the time. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), on this admission, showed a mass lesion in the left frontal operculum with poorly identified margins and right-sided midline shift. Sampling from the left temporal lobe showed an IDH-mutant, ATRX-mutant astrocytoma, which appeared grade 4 in the enhancing anterior portion and grade 2 in the left temporal lobe. Methylation analysis confirmed this heterogeneity. In summary, this is an excellent example of tumor heterogeneity both histologically and by molecular analysis. It is probable, given the clinical history of presentation 2 years prior, that this tumor originated as a low-grade glioma and subsequently evolved.