The current challenge in using extracellular vesicles (EVs) as drug delivery vehicles is to precisely control their membrane permeability, specifically in the ability to switch between permeable and impermeable states without compromising their integrity and functionality. Here, we introduce a rapid, efficient, and gentle loading method for EVs based on tonicity control (TC) using a lab-on-a-disc platform. In this technique, a hypotonic solution was used for temporarily permeabilizing a membrane ("on" state), allowing the influx of molecules into EVs. The subsequent isotonic washing led to an impermeable membrane ("off" state). This loading cycle enables the loading of different cargos into EVs, such as doxorubicin hydrochloride (Dox), ssDNA, and miRNA. The TC approach was shown to be more effective than traditional methods such as sonication or extrusion, with loading yields that were 4.3-fold and 7.2-fold greater, respectively. Finally, the intracellular assessments of miRNA-497-loaded EVs and doxorubicin-loaded EVs confirmed the superior performance of TC-prepared formulations and demonstrated the impact of encapsulation heterogeneity on the therapeutic outcome, signifying potential opportunities for developing novel exosome-based therapeutic systems for clinical applications.