Large strides have been made in designing an ever-increasing set of modern organic materials of high functionality and thus, often, of high complexity, including semiconducting polymers, organic ferroelectrics, light-emitting small molecules, and beyond. Here, we review how broadly applied thermal analysis methodologies, especially differential scanning calorimetry, can be utilized to provide unique information on the assembly and solid-state structure of this extensive class of materials, as well as the phase behavior of intrinsically intricate multicomponent systems. Indeed, highly relevant insights can be gained that are useful, e.g., for further materials-discovery activities and the establishment of reliable processing protocols, in particular if combined with X-ray diffraction techniques, spectroscopic tools, and scanning electron microscopy enabled by vapor-phase infiltration staining. We, hence, illustrate that insights far richer than simple melting point- and glass-transition identification can be obtained with differential scanning calorimetry, rendering it a critical methodology to understand complex matter, including functional macromolecules and blends. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Physical Chemistry, Volume 75 is April 2024. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.