Efficacy and specificity of melanopsin reporters for retinal ganglion cells

Abstract

Intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells (ipRGCs) are specialized retinal output neurons that mediate behavioral, neuroendocrine, and developmental responses to environmental light. There are diverse molecular strategies for marking ipRGCs, especially in mice, making them among the best characterized retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). With the development of more sensitive reporters, new subtypes of ipRGCs have emerged. We therefore tested high-sensitivity reporter systems to see whether we could reveal yet more. Substantial confusion remains about which of the available methods, if any, label all and only ipRGCs. Here, we compared many different methods for labeling of ipRGCs, including anti-melanopsin immunofluorescence, Opn4-GFP BAC transgenic mice, and Opn4^cre mice crossed with three different Cre-specific reporters (Z/EG, Ai9, and Ai14) or injected with Cre-dependent (DIO) AAV2. We show that Opn4^cre mice, when crossed with sensitive Cre-reporter mice, label numerous ganglion cell types that lack intrinsic photosensitivity. Though other methods label ipRGCs specifically, they do not label the entire population of ipRGCs. We conclude that no existing method labels all and only ipRGCs. We assess the appropriateness of each reporter for particular applications and integrate findings across reporters to estimate that the overall abundance of ipRGCs among mouse RGCs may approach 11%.