Evaluating end-to-end continuous antibody manufacture with column-free capture alternatives from economic, environmental, and robustness perspectives

Abstract

Process intensification efforts have renewed interest in the potential of end-to-end continuous manufacture with column-free capture alternatives. This article describes a decisional tool that encompasses mass balance and design equations, process economics, stochastic simulation and multi-criteria decision-making and enables the evaluation of different batch, and continuous flowsheets for monoclonal antibody (mAb) manufacture. The traditional batch process was compared with end-to-end continuous bioprocesses with either protein A capture or column-free capture employing aqueous two-phase extraction or precipitation from economic, environmental, and robustness perspectives. The cost of goods analysis predicted that continuous flowsheets could offer substantial cost savings (~20%-40%) over the batch process at low and medium annual commercial demands (100-500 kg); however, at tonnage demands they resulted in either comparable or higher costs. Comparing the continuous options, the continuous flowsheets with protein A or precipitation yielded similar COG/g values, while aqueous two-phase extraction presented higher costs. The analysis of overall process mass intensities accounting for water and consumables suggested that the continuous flowsheet with protein A would result in the lowest environmental burden. When the economic, environmental, and operational criteria were reconciled using multi-criteria decision-making analysis, the continuous protein A-based flowsheet was found to be the most favorable. A target analysis highlighted the need for process improvements in the following parameters to reduce the manufacturing costs of the continuous column-free capture options below that of protein A: the perfusion volumetric productivity, the harvested cell culture fluid percentage in column-free operations, the column-free step yields along with the implementation of buffer concentrates.

Keywords: aqueous two-phase extraction; cost of goods; monoclonal antibody manufacturing; precipitation; process economics; protein A chromatography.