Gut microbiota produce tryptophan metabolites (TMs) important to homeostasis. However, measuring TM levels in stool and determining their microbial sources can be difficult. Here, we measured TMs from the indole pathway in fecal samples from 21 healthy adults with the goal to: 1) determine fecal TM concentrations in healthy individuals; 2) link TM levels to bacterial abundance using 16S and whole genome shotgun (WGS) sequencing data; and 3) predict likely bacterial sources of TM production. Within our samples, we identified 151 genera (16S) and 592 bacterial species (WGS). Eight TMs were found in ≥17 fecal samples, including four in all persons. To our knowledge, we are the first to report fecal levels for indole-3-lactate, indole-3-propionate, and 3-indoleacrylate levels in healthy persons. Overall, indole, indole-3-acetate (IAA), and skatole accounted for 86% of the eight TMs measured. Significant correlations were found between seven TMs and 29 bacterial species. Predicted multiple TM sources support the notion of a complex network of TM production and regulation. Further, the data suggest key roles for Collinsella aerofaciens and IAA, a metabolite reported to maintain intestinal homeostasis through enhanced barrier integrity and anti-inflammatory/antioxidant activities. These findings extend our understanding of TMs and their relationship to the microbial species that act as effectors and/or regulators in the healthy intestine and may lead to novel strategies designed to manipulate tryptophan metabolism to prevent disease and/or restore health to the dysbiotic gut.