Mussels are marine organisms that are capable of constructing an underwater adhesion between their bodies and rigid structures. It is well known that mussels achieve underwater adhesion through the presence of mussel adhesive proteins (MAPs) that contain high levels of 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (DOPA). Although the extraordinary underwater adhesive properties of mussels are attributed to DOPA, its capacity to play a dual role in surface adhesion and internal cohesion is inherently limited. However, mussels employ a combination of chemical moieties, not just DOPA, along with anatomical components, such as plaque and byssus, in underwater adhesion. This also involves junction proteins that connect the plaque and byssus. In this study, a novel hybrid MAP was bioengineered via the fusion of the plaque protein (foot protein type 1) and the histidine-rich domain of the junction protein (foot protein type 4). To achieve direct adhesion underwater, the adhesive should maintain surface adhesion without disintegrating. Notably, the histidine-Zn-coordinated hybrid MAP hydrogel maintained a high surface adhesion ability even after cross-linking because of the preservation of its unoxidized and non-cross-linked DOPA moieties. The formulated adhesive hydrogel system based on the bioengineered hybrid MAP exhibited self-healing properties, owing to the reversible metal coordination bonds. The developed adhesive hydrogel exhibits outstanding levels of bulk adhesion in underwater environments, highlighting its potential as an effective adhesive biomaterial. Therefore, the introduction of histidine-rich domains into MAPs may be applied in various studies to formulate mussel-inspired adhesives with self-healing properties and to fully utilize the adhesive ability of DOPA.