Plasmonic nanoparticles, due to their sensitivity to small changes in their closest environment and plasmon resonance, can sense the chirality of the surrounding molecules. Therefore, plasmonic nanoparticles can be applied as a next-generation biosensor for peptides or proteins. In this work, we explore the interaction between chiral, ordered protein aggregates (amyloids) and small gold nanobipyramids. We show how the morphology, structure, and chiroptical properties of amyloids induce circular dichroism in the plasmon resonance wavelengths from individual plasmonic nanoparticles upon binding to the chiral amyloid template. Moreover, using the data from microscopic and spectroscopic analyses of formed heterostructures, we propose the most probable mechanism behind the induction of chirality in this system and discuss which specific feature of insulin protein aggregates is sensed by nanobipyramids.