Investigations of saturated spirocycles toward selective C-H functionalization reactions are scarce, despite their potential applications. In this work, we uncovered fundamental reactivity and selectivity differences between saturated heterocycles and their spirocyclic analogues using a model radical C-H xanthylation coupled with computational analysis. Ultimately, this study sheds light on the fundamental, understudied radical reactivity of spirocycles, thereby allowing for a pronounced chemical tunability that will prove to be advantageous in the expansion of their chemical space and applications in medicinal chemistry.