Conversations about evidence have become much more personal and more divisive over the course of the COVID-19 pandemic. Using a metaphor to carefully consider all the different aspects of "seeing" evidence can remind us that assembling a complete picture of information on any topic is necessarily a communal effort, made more robust by actively seeking to learn about and mitigate our blind spots. An approach to evidence that is curious, humble, and seeks relationship and partnership with others can help us see more clearly and completely.