Assessing the impact of COVID-19 on outpatient and inpatient revenues: A comparative analysis of large and small hospitals in Taiwan

Abstract

Background: The COVID-19 pandemic has had profound effects on healthcare systems worldwide, not only by straining medical resources but also by significantly impacting hospital revenues. These economic repercussions have varied across different hospital departments and facility sizes. This study posits that outpatient (OPD) revenues experienced greater reductions than inpatient (IPD) revenues and that the financial impact was more profound in larger hospitals than in smaller hospitals.

Methods: We collected data on patient case numbers and associated revenues for 468 hospitals from the Taiwan government-run National Health Insurance Administration website. We then employed Microsoft Excel to construct scatter plots using the trigonometric function (=DEGREES (Atan (growth rate))) for each hospital. Our analysis scrutinized 4 areas: the case numbers and the revenues (represented by medical fees) submitted to the Taiwan government-run National Health Insurance Administration in both March and April of 2019 and 2020 for OPD and IPD departments. The validity of our hypotheses was established through correlation coefficients (CCs) and chi-square tests. Moreover, to visualize and substantiate the hypothesis under study, we utilized the Kano diagram. A higher CC indicates consistent counts and revenues between 2019 and 2020.

Results: Our findings indicated a higher impact on OPDs, with CCs of 0.79 and 0.83, than on IPDs, which had CCs of 0.40 and 0.18. Across all hospital types, there was a consistent impact on OPDs (P = .14 and 0.46). However, a significant variance was observed in the impact on IPDs (P < .001), demonstrating that larger hospitals faced greater revenue losses than smaller facilities, especially in their inpatient departments.

Conclusion: The two hypotheses confirmed that the COVID-19 pandemic impacted outpatient departments more than inpatient departments. Larger hospitals in Taiwan faced greater financial challenges, especially in inpatient sectors, underscoring the pandemic's varied economic effects. The COVID-19 pandemic disproportionately affected outpatient departments and larger hospitals in Taiwan. Policymakers must prioritize support for these areas to ensure healthcare resilience in future epidemics. The research approach used in this study can be utilized as a model for similar research in other countries affected by COVID-19.