Fewer polymer chains but higher adhesion: How gradient-stiffness hydrogel layers mediate adhesion through network stretch

Abstract

The presence of gradient softer outer layers, commonly observed in biological systems (such as cartilage and ocular tissues), as well as synthetic crosslinked hydrogels, profoundly influences their interactions with opposing surfaces. Our prior research demonstrated that gradient-stiffness hydrogel layers, characterized by increasing elasticity with depth, control contact mechanics, particularly in proximity to the layer thickness. We postulate that the distribution of polymers within these gradient layers imparts extraordinary stretch and adhesion characteristics due to network adaptability and stress-induced reorganization. To investigate this phenomenon, we utilized Atomic Force Microscopy nanoindentation to assess the depth-dependent adhesion behavior of polyacrylamide hydrogels with varying gradient layer thicknesses. Two gradient layer thicknesses were achieved by employing different molding materials: glass and polyoxymethylene (POM). Glass-molded hydrogels exhibited a thinner gradient layer alongside a stiffer bulk layer compared to their POM-molded counterparts. In indentation experiments, the POM-molded hydrogel had larger adhesion compared to glass-molded hydrogel. We find that indenting within the gradient layer engenders increased load-unload hysteresis due to heightened fluid transport in the sparse outer polymer network. Consequently, this led to augmented adhesion and work of separation at shallow depths. We suggest that the prominent stretching capability of the sparse outer polymer network during probe retraction contributes to enhanced adhesion. The Maugis-Dugdale adhesive model only fits well to indentations on the thin layer or indentations which engage significantly with the bulk. These results facilitate a comprehensive characterization of adhesion mechanics in gradient-stiffness hydrogels, which could foster their application across emerging contexts in health science and environmental domains.