The effect of mixed forest identity on soil carbon stocks in Pinus massoniana mixed forests

Abstract

Increased productivity generally promotes the accumulation of soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks. The productivity of mixed forests is mainly influenced by plant species richness (PSR), mixed forest age (MFA), and mixed species proportion (MSP). However, the influence of PSR, MFA, and MSP on SOC stocks along the soil profiles in Pinus massoniana mixed forests remains to be determined. We conducted a meta-analysis employing paired observations of SOC stocks from 1010 paired mixed and pure stands of P. massoniana from 110 publications. The findings revealed that SOC stocks were highly dependent on MFA and increased with increasing MFA in various soil layers, rather than the expected influence of PSR. MFA contributed 48.97 %, 83.20 %, and 38.41 % to the increased SOC stocks in the topsoil, midsoil, and subsoil, respectively. Furthermore, MSP also significantly affected the increase in SOC stock in the topsoil and midsoil when 40 % < MSP ≤ 60 %. Over the next 60 years, subsoil SOC accumulation will be limited by increased PSR and MSP in mixed forests. Mixing between P. massoniana and broadleaf tree species (especially Schima superba and Lespedeza bicolor) significantly enhanced SOC stocks along the soil profiles. SOC stocks along the soil profiles decreased with increasing dominant mixed tree species richness (e.g., broadleaf, deciduous broadleaf, arbuscular mycorrhizal, and the sum of conifer and broadleaf trees). Incorporating lower PSR (e.g., 2 ≤ N ≤ 10) and dominant mixed tree species richness (e.g., N = 2) practices may be optimization options for increasing SOC stocks. Overall, based on the expected goals, including optimizing productivity, enhancing carbon storage, mitigating climate change, and promoting biodiversity conservation, we emphasize the importance of incorporating MFA, MSP, tree species identity, and subsoil into forest management.

Keywords: Mixed forest age; Mixed species proportion; Plant species richness; Soil carbon sequestration; Subsoil; Tree species identity.