Genetic selection for reduced health treatment costs in Holstein cows: implications from a long-term study

Abstract

The objective of this study was to estimate genetic parameters of health treatment cost of Holstein cows from producer-recorded health treatments in 8 herds over an 8-yr period of time. Genetic parameters of health treatment cost were estimated in first (n = 2,214), second (n = 1,487) and third (n = 800) parities of US Holstein cows. The health treatments were uniformly defined and consistently recorded by 8 high-performance dairy herds in Minnesota from 2008 to 2015. A fixed treatment cost was assigned to 14 types of health treatments, and the cost included the mean veterinary expense obtained from the veterinary clinics that serviced the 8 herds, pharmaceuticals, and labor cost. The labor cost was $18/h, and the time incurred for each type of health treatment was determined from interviews with the herd owners. The 14 types of health treatment costs were partitioned into 5 categories: mastitis (including mastitis diagnostic test), reproduction (cystic ovary, retained placenta, and metritis), lameness (hoof treatments), metabolic (milk fever, displaced abomasum, ketosis, and digestive), and miscellaneous (respiratory, injury, and other). Health treatment cost for each cow was summed by category within lactation and also across categories within lactation. The estimates of heritability for health treatment cost were 0.13, 0.04, 0.10, 0.12, and 0.04 for the mastitis, reproduction, lameness, metabolic, and miscellaneous categories, respectively, in first parity. Genetic correlations between categories of health treatment cost in first parity were greatest for mastitis and reproduction (r = 0.85); however, phenotypic correlations between all categories were small (r < 0.16). Total health treatment cost had a large genetic correlation with somatic cell score (0.93) and 305-d milk production (0.44) in first parity; however, the genetic correlation (-0.60) between total health treatment cost and udder depth in first parity indicated a genetic relationship exists between shallow udders and less total health treatment cost. Total health treatment cost across categories had a heritability estimate of 0.25 in first parity, 0.16 in second parity, and 0.17 in third parity. Consequently, genetic selection for reduced health treatment cost should be possible by using producer-recorded health treatment records supplemented with treatment costs.

Keywords: Holstein; conformation; dairy cattle; health cost; type traits.