Global facial soft tissue thicknesses for craniofacial identification (2023): a review of 140 years of data since Welcker's first study

Int J Legal Med. 2024 Mar;138(2):519-535. doi: 10.1007/s00414-023-03087-x. Epub 2023 Oct 7.

Abstract

This year (2023) marks 140 years since the first publication of a facial soft tissue thickness (FSTT) study. Since 1883, a total of 139 studies have been published, collectively tallying > 220,000 tissue thickness measurements of > 19,500 adults. In just the last 5-years, 33 FSTT studies have been conducted. Herein, we add these data (plus an additional 20 studies) to the 2018 T-Table to provide an update of > 81,000 new datapoints to the global tallied facial soft tissue depths table. In contrast to the original 2008 T-Table, some notable changes are as follows: increased FSTTs by 3 mm at infra second molar (ecm2-iM2'), 2.5 mm at gonion (go-go'), 2 mm at mid-ramus (mr-mr'), and 1.5 mm at zygion (zy-zy'). Rolling grand means indicate that stable values have been attained for all nine median FSTT landmarks, while six out of nine bilateral landmarks continue to show ongoing fluctuations, indicating further data collection at these landmarks holds value. When used as point estimators for individuals with known values across 24 landmarks (i.e., C-Table data), the updated grand means produce slightly less estimation error than the 2018 T-Table means (3.5 mm versus 3.6 mm, respectively). Future efforts to produce less noisy datasets (i.e., reduce measurement and sampling errors as much as possible between studies) would be useful.

Keywords: Craniofacial identification; Face; Facial approximation; Facial soft tissue depth; Skull.

Publication types

  • Review

MeSH terms

  • Adult
  • Anatomic Landmarks*
  • Data Collection
  • Face* / anatomy & histology
  • Forensic Anthropology
  • Humans
  • Molar