Test-retest reliability of quantitative sensory testing, active joint position sense, and functional hop testing in amateur adult athletes with unilateral anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Abstract

Objectives: The somatosensory system fulfils a critical role in functional knee joint stability (FKJS) by providing afferent feedback necessary for neuromuscular control. Individuals with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLr) have altered somatosensory function. Somatosensory characteristics are assessed by proprioception and quantitative sensory testing. The purpose of the study was to examine intra-rater and inter-rater reliability of methods used to assess somatosensory characteristics and FKJS in amateur adult athletes with unilateral ACLr.

Design: Repeated measures.

Setting: University.

Participants: 8 female, 4 male with unilateral autogenous ACLr.

Main outcome measures: Bilateral measurements at 5 lower extremity locations and the anterior forearm: light touch (LT), vibration sense (VS), pressure pain threshold (PPT); knee active joint position sense (AJPS); adapted crossover hop for distance (ACHD). Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) determined reliability, defined as: poor (<0.50), moderate (0.50-0.75), good (0.75-0.90).

Results: ACLr-side intra-rater/inter-rater ICCs ranged: LT, -0.27-0.80/-0.01-0.84; VS, 0.12-0.90/0.25-0.90; PPT, 0.49-0.98/0.86-0.99; AJPS, 0.15-0.79/0.55-0.87; ACHD, 0.98/0.99. Uninjured-side intra-rater/inter-rater ICCs ranged: LT, 0.12-0.66/-0.09-0.64; VS, 0.35-0.89/0.05-0.81; PPT, 0.65-0.99/0.45-0.95; AJPS, 0.07-0.81/0.37-0.99; ACHD, 0.99/0.98.

Conclusions: Intra-rater and inter-rater reliability was poor to good for both limbs. Overall, PPT and the ACHD demonstrated the highest ICCs. Some somatosensory assessments can be employed with confidence, while others should be used with caution.

Keywords: Anterior cruciate ligament; Knee; Proprioception; Quantitative sensory testing.