Novel item selection strategies for cognitive diagnostic computerized adaptive testing: A heuristic search framework

Behav Res Methods. 2023 Sep 25. doi: 10.3758/s13428-023-02228-9. Online ahead of print.

Abstract

The computerized adaptive form of cognitive diagnostic testing, CD-CAT, has gained increasing attention in the domain of personalized measurements for its ability to categorize individual mastery status of fine-grained attributes more accurately and efficiently through administering items tailored to one's ability progressively. How to select the next item based on previous response(s) is crucial for the success of CD-CAT. Previous item selection strategies for CD-CAT have often followed a greedy or semi-greedy approach, which makes it difficult to strike a balance between diagnostic performance and item bank utilization. To address this issue, this study takes a graph perspective and transforms the item selection problem in CD-CAT into a path-searching problem, in which paths refer to possible test construction and nodes refer to individual items. A heuristic function is defined to predict the prospect of a path, indicating how well the corresponding test can diagnose the current examinee. Two search mechanisms with different biases towards item exposure control are proposed to approximate the optimal path with the best prospect. The first unused item on the resulting path is selected as the next item. The above components compose a novel CD-CAT item selection framework based on heuristic search. Simulation studies are conducted under a variety of conditions regarding bank designs, bank-quality conditions, and testing scenarios. The results are compared with different types of classic item selection strategies in CD-CAT, showing that the proposed framework can enhance bank utilization at a smaller cost of diagnostic performance.

Keywords: Cognitive diagnostic testing; Computerized adaptive testing; Heuristic search.