AbstractMarine invertebrates with biphasic life cycles feature life history transitions that coincide with habitat changes from benthic adults to planktonic embryos and larvae, then a return to the benthos as a juvenile at metamorphosis. The metamorphic transition exposes animals to a new suite of benthic predators, and high mortality often occurs in the hours and days following settlement. Juvenile invertebrates may produce phenotypically plastic morphological defenses when predator cues are detected. However, time lags inherent to phenotypic plasticity may delay the production of defenses until after the period of highest vulnerability. It should, therefore, be beneficial for planktonic larvae approaching settlement to detect waterborne cues from benthic predators and produce juvenile phenotypes appropriate for postmetamorphic survival. Echinoderms are useful models for testing transhabitat and trans-life history stage phenotypic plasticity because many species have larvae that construct their juvenile phenotype while still in the water column. In this study, we tested whether planktonic echinoderm larvae exposed to cues from benthic predators modified their juvenile phenotypes at settlement. Green urchin (Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis) and Pacific sand dollar (Dendraster excentricus) larvae were exposed to predatory green crab (Carcinus maenus) or red rock crab (Cancer productus) cues, respectively, from their early-stage juvenile rudiment formation through settlement. Green urchin larvae exposed to predator cues settled with significantly more juvenile spines compared to unexposed controls. Sand dollars exhibited earlier settlement, larger disk area, fewer spines, and shorter spines when exposed to benthic predator cues. Sand dollar larvae were also exposed to cues from planktonic crab larvae and in response settled sooner and larger, with even fewer and shorter spines than those exposed to benthic predator cues. These results suggest that echinoderm larvae alter their juvenile phenotype in response to predator cues, but the response varies between species, and responses to planktonic threats may be prioritized over benthic ones.