The rise of gemination in Celtic

Open Res Eur. 2024 Feb 8:3:24. doi: 10.12688/openreseurope.15400.1. eCollection 2023.

Abstract

This study investigates systematically the emergence and establishment of geminate consonants as a phonological class in the Celtic branch of Indo-European. The approach of this study is comparative historical linguistics, drawing on diachronic structuralism combined with aspects of language contact studies and functional approaches to language usage. This study traces the development of geminates from Proto-Indo-European (fourth millennium B.C.), which did not allow geminate consonants, to the Common Celtic period (first millennium B.C.), when almost every consonant could occur as a singleton or as a geminate, and on to the earliest attested stages of the Insular Celtic languages (first millennium A.D.). Although they were prominent in the phonology of Proto- and Ancient Celtic (Gaulish, Celtiberian), ultimately geminates were gotten rid of as a phonological class in the individual Insular Celtic languages. This is probably due to the fact that the contrast between lenited and unlenited sounds took on a central role in Insular Celtic phonology, making gemination a phonetically redundant category. Most instances of geminate consonants in Celtic can be explained by regular sound change operating on inherited clusters of consonants. Each sound change will be discussed in a separate section in a rough chronological order. Effectively, gemination is largely a strategy to reduce the number of allowed consonant combinations. To a limited degree, gemination also had a morphological function, especially in the formation of personal names and in the creation of adjectival neologisms. However, there is a residue of words, especially nouns, in the Insular Celtic languages that defy any attempt at etymologising. They are prime suspects of having been borrowed from prehistoric, substratal languages.

Keywords: Celtic linguistics; Indo-European linguistics; geminate consonants; historical linguistcs; substrate linguistics.

Plain language summary

Geminate, i.e., ‘double’ or ‘long’, consonants were very common in Proto- and Ancient Celtic languages, such as Gaulish or Celtiberian of the first millennium B.C. and earlier. They were also very prominent in the prehistory of the Insular Celtic languages, e.g. Irish, Welsh or Breton, but they were abandoned as a class of sounds shortly before the attestation of those languages due to other developments in those languages, especially the rise of lenited sounds as a grammatically very important class. This important role of geminates in Celtic contrasts with the situation in its ancestor language, reconstructed Proto-Indo-European (ca. middle fourth millennium B.C.), which effectively disallowed geminate consonants. This article explains how geminate consonants arose step by step in the prehistory and the early history of Celtic, mostly by regular sound change operating on inherited words. In addition, gemination became prominent in the formation of personal names and in the creation of new adjectives. However, a group of nouns with geminates finds no explanation within the traditional framework of historical linguistics. It is suggested that they are due to borrowings from prehistoric, lost languages in the west of Europe.

Grants and funding

This project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme(s) (grant agreement No(s) 647351 & 716732).