PIC cystography in occult vesicoureteral reflux: A systematic review highlighting its utility in children with recurrent urinary tract infections and normal VCUG

Abstract

Background: Vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) affects 1-2% of children, predisposing them to pyelonephritis, renal scarring, and reflux nephropathy. Treatment aims to prevent febrile urinary tract infections (f-UTI) and long-term sequelae. While guidelines differ, the current consensus proposes individual risk-stratification and subsequent management strategies. Here, we systematically analyzed the current literature on Positional Instillation of Contrast Cystography (PIC) for individualized diagnostics in patients with recurrent f-UTIs.

Objective: We present a comprehensive qualitative and quantitative synthesis. Outcomes were: 1. the ability of PIC to predict VUR in patients with negative voiding cystographies (VCUG), 2. the ability of PIC to predict occult contralateral VUR, 3. the correlation of occult VUR in PIC with dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) scan findings, and 4. the incidence of postoperative f-UTI in children treated for occult VUR picked up on PIC.

Study design: We conducted a systematic review following the PRISMA guidelines, applying the following inclusion criteria: Children with occult VUR in PIC with negative VCUG.

Results: We included nine studies with 496 symptomatic patients with a mean age of 6.8 years, published between 2003 and 2021. PIC detected VUR in 73% of patients. Out of them, 81% had low-grade and 19% high-grade VUR. Occult contralateral VUR was present in 41% children. The presence of renal scars on DMSA scan was 1.39 times more likely with occult VUR on PIC. 85% of patients did not experience recurrent f-UTIs after PIC and subsequent treatment.

Discussion: PIC can detect occult VUR in patients with recurrent f-UTIs in whom VCUG is negative. However, we recommend a cautious approach in the use of PIC in clinical practice until further prospective studies confirm the validity of our outcome measures.

Conclusion: Identification, risk stratification, and prompt action are central in managing VUR. PIC can be helpful in identifying VUR in patients with recurrent f-UTI.

Keywords: Positional instillation contrast cystography; Recurrent febrile urinary tract infections; Vesicoureteral reflux.