An ongoing challenge in precision medicine is the efficient delivery of therapeutics to tissues/organs of interest. Nanoparticle delivery systems have the potential to overcome traditional limitations of drug and gene delivery through improved pharmacokinetics, tissue targeting, and stability of encapsulated cargo. Physalis mottle virus (PhMV)-like nanoparticles are a promising nanocarrier platform which can be chemically targeted on the exterior and interior surfaces through reactive amino acids. Cargo-loading to the internal cavity is achieved with thiol-reactive small molecules. However, the internal loading capacity of these nanoparticles is limited by the presence of a single reactive cysteine (C75) per coat protein with low inherent reactivity. Here, we use structure-based design to engineer cysteine-added mutants of PhMV VLPs that display increased reactivity toward thiol-reactive small molecules. Specifically, the A31C and S137C mutants show a greater than 10-fold increased rate of reactivity towards thiol-reactive small molecules, and PhMV Cys1 (A31C), PhMV Cys2 (S137C), and PhMV Cys1+2 (double mutant) VLPs display up to three-fold increased internal loading of the small molecule chemotherapeutics aldoxorubicin and vcMMAE and up to four-fold increased internal loading of the MRI imaging reagent DOTA(Gd). These results further improve upon a promising plant virus-based nanocarrier system for use in targeted delivery of small-molecule drugs and imaging reagents in vivo.