Immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif (ITAM)-containing Fc receptors are critical components of the innate and adaptive immune systems. FcεRI mediates the allergic response via crosslinking of IgE-bound receptors by multivalent antigens. Yet, the underlying molecular mechanisms that govern the response of FcεRI to specific antigens remain poorly understood. We compared responses induced by two antigens with distinct geometries, high valency DNP-BSA and trivalent DF3, and found unique secretion and receptor phosphorylation profiles that are due to differential recruitment of Lyn and SHIP1. To understand how these two antigens can cause such markedly different outcomes, we used direct stochastic optical reconstruction microscopy (dSTORM) super-resolution imaging combined with Bayesian Grouping of Localizations (BaGoL) analysis to compare the nanoscale characteristics of FcεRI aggregates. DF3 aggregates were found to be smaller and more densely packed than DNP-BSA aggregates. Using lifetime-based Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements, we discovered that FcεRI subunits undergo structural rearrangements upon crosslinking with either antigen, and in response to interaction with monovalent antigen presented on a supported lipid bilayer. The extent of conformational change is positively correlated with signaling efficiency. Finally, we provide evidence for forces in optimizing FcεRI signaling, such that immobilizing DF3 on a rigid surface promoted degranulation while increasing DNP-BSA flexibility lowered degranulation. These results provide a link between the physical attributes of allergens, including size, shape, valency, and flexibility, and FcεRI signaling strength. Thus, the antigen modulates mast cell outcomes by creating unique aggregate geometries that tune FcεRI conformation, phosphorylation and signaling partner recruitment.