The current study investigates SET-promoted photoaddition reactions of the silyl-group-containing N-phenylglycinates and N-phenylalaninates, N-((trimethylsilyl)methyl)-N-phenyl-substituted glycinates and alaninates, respectively, with fullerene C60 to explore how the types of amino acid esters (AAEs) and molecular oxygen affect the photoaddition reaction efficiencies and chemoselectivity of in situ formed radical cations of AAEs. The results showed that under deoxygenated (N2-purged) conditions, photoreactions of N-phenylglycinates with C60 produced aminomethyl-1,2-dihydrofullerenes through the addition of α-amino radicals arising by sequential SET and desilylation processes from initially formed secondary anilines to C60. In oxygenated conditions, photoreactions of N-phenylglycinates with C60, albeit less efficient, took place to form fulleropyrrolidines through a pathway involving 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of azomethine ylides to C60 assisted by in situ formed 1O2. The same types of photoproducts were observed with N-phenylalaninates, though the reactions were less efficient. The use of methylene blue (MB) as a photosensitizer in the photoreactions under oxygenated conditions was especially effective in enhancing the efficiency of fulleropyrrolidine formation. These results demonstrate that photoaddition reactions of silyl-tether-containing N-phenyl AAEs with C60 can be governed by the reaction conditions and the presence or absence of a photosensitizer employed.