The long-term effects of aggressive spasticity reducing treatment, including selective dorsal rhizotomy, on joint kinematic outcomes of persons with cerebral palsy

Abstract

Background: Selective dorsal rhizotomy (SDR) creates a large and permanent reduction of spasticity for children with cerebral palsy (CP). Previous SDR outcomes studies have generally lacked appropriate control groups, had limited sample sizes, or reported short-term follow-up, limiting evidence for improvement in long-term gait function.

Research question: Does aggressive spasticity management for individuals with CP improve long-term gait kinematics (discrete joint kinematics) compared to a control group of individuals with CP with minimal spasticity management?

Methods: This study was a secondary analysis - focused on joint-level kinematics - of a previous study evaluating the long-term outcomes of SDR. Two groups of participants were recruited based on a retrospectively completed baseline clinical gait study. One group received aggressive spasticity treatment including a selective dorsal rhizotomy (Yes-SDR group), while the other group had minimal spasticity management (No-SDR group). Both groups had orthopedic surgery treatment. Groups were matched on baseline spasticity. All participants prospectively returned for a follow-up gait study in young adulthood (greater than 21 years of age and at least 10 years after baseline). Change scores in discrete kinematic variables from baseline to follow-up were assessed using a linear model that included treatment arm (Yes-SDR, No-SDR), baseline age, and baseline kinematic value. For treatment arm, 5° and 5 Gait Deviation Index points were selected as thresholds to be considered a meaningful difference between treatment groups.

Results: At follow-up, there were no meaningful differences in pelvis, hip, knee, or ankle kinematic variable changes between treatment arms. Max knee flexion - swing showed a moderate treatment effect for Yes-SDR, although it did not reach the defined threshold.

Significance: Aggressive spasticity treatment does not result in meaningful differences in gait kinematics for persons with cerebral palsy in young adulthood compared to minimal spasticity management with both groups having orthopedic surgery.

Keywords: Cerebral palsy; Gait; Long-term outcome; Selective dorsal rhizotomy; Spasticity.