TLC and HPTLC-APCI-MS for the rapid discrimination of plant resins frequently used for lacquers and varnishes by artists and conservators

Abstract

Introduction: Depending on their terpenoid and phenolic constituents plant resins can be classified as diterpenoid, triterpenoid or phenolic resins; thereby the profile of diterpenes and triterpenes is considered as genus- or even species-specific.

Objectives: We aimed to develop a simple, rapid, inexpensive, sensitive and specific method for the identification of resin-specific triterpenoid and phenolic compounds in plant resins using (HP)TLC [(high-performance) thin-layer chromatography] combined with APCI-MS (atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation mass spectrometry) and post-chromatographic detection reactions.

Methods: Twenty resin samples from different plant species were analysed. Different extraction procedures, post-chromatographic detection reagents as well as various sorbents and solvents for planar chromatography were tested. To evaluate the potential of the optimised (HP)TLC-APCI-MS methods, parameter such as limit of detection (LOD) was determined for selected marker compounds.

Results: Our protocol enabled qualitative analyses of chemotaxonomic molecular markers in natural resins such as dammar, mastic, olibanum and benzoin. For the first time, the application of thionyl chloride-stannic chloride reagent for a specific post-chromatographic detection of triterpenes is reported, sometimes even allowing discrimination between isomers based on their characteristic colour sequences. For triterpene acids, triterpene alcohols and phenolic compounds, detection limits of 2-20 ng/TLC zone and a system precision with a relative standard deviation (RSD) in the range of 3.9%-7.0% were achieved by (HP)TLC-APCI-MS. The applicability of the method for the analysis of resin-based varnishes was successfully tested on a mastic-based varnish. Thus, the method we propose is a helpful tool for the discrimination of resins and resin-based varnishes with respect to their botanical origin.

Keywords: HPTLC-MS; benzoin balsam; plant resin; triterpene; varnish.