Virtual Reality for Preoperative Planning in Complex Surgical Oncology: A Single-Center Experience

Abstract

Introduction: Virtual reality models (VRM) are three-dimensional (3D) simulations of two-dimensional (2D) images, creating a more accurate mental representation of patient-specific anatomy.

Methods: Patients were retrospectively identified who underwent complex oncologic resections whose operations differed from preoperative plans between April 2018 and April 2019. Virtual reality modeling was performed based on preoperative 2D images to assess feasibility of use of this technology to create models. Preoperative plans made based upon 2D imaging versus VRM were compared to the final operations performed. Once the use of VRM to create preoperative plans was deemed feasible, individuals undergoing complex oncologic resections whose operative plans were difficult to define preoperatively were enrolled prospectively from July 2019 to December 2021. Preoperative plans made based upon 2D imaging and VRM by both the operating surgeon and a consulting surgeon were compared to the operation performed. Confidence in each operative plan was also measured.

Results: Twenty patients were identified, seven retrospective and 13 prospective, with tumors of the liver, pancreas, retroperitoneum, stomach, and soft tissue. Retrospectively, VRM were unable to be created in one patient due to a poor quality 2D image; the remainder (86%) were successfully able to be created and examined. Virtual reality modeling more clearly defined the extent of resection in 50% of successful cases. Prospectively, all VRM were successfully performed. The concordance of the operative plan with VRM was higher than with 2D imaging (92% versus 54% for the operating surgeon and 69% versus 23% for the consulting surgeon). Confidence in the operative plan after VRM compared to 2D imaging also increased for both surgeons (by 15% and 8% for the operating and consulting surgeons, respectively).

Conclusions: Virtual reality modeling is feasible and may improve preoperative planning compared to 2D imaging. Further investigation is warranted.

Keywords: Preoperative care; Surgical oncology; Three-dimensional imaging; Three-dimensional printing; Virtual reality.