Effectiveness of biochar as an adsorbent for pesticides: Systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

The use of pesticides is intense in agriculture and has caused contamination in water, air and soil. This fact led to the need to study strategies that can minimize the effects that these pesticides have caused to the environment. In this context, biochar appears, as a type of material that has the ability to remove chemical substances, and because they can be activated with different chemical agents, they are extremely effective in the adsorption of toxic substances. Therefore, the aim of the study was to evaluate the use of biochar as a bioadsorbent for pesticides. This is a systematic review with meta-analysis and meta-regression, as the PRISMA protocol recommendations. Studies from the last 20 years were included, with at least the abstract available and considering preferentially experimental studies. Qualitative studies or studies with high risk of bias, other reviews and duplicates were excluded. The variables analyzed were the presence of factors that prove the effectiveness or not of pesticide adsorption. Studies with a superficial approach or those that do not show positivity or negativity in relation to the outcome were excluded. The search was conducted on the sources: Scopus, Web of Science electronic databases, PubMed (of the US National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health) and ScienceDirect (Elsevier). For better investigative determination, the data were searched separately. The descriptors used for the search were the following: Agrochemicals AND Activated Carbon AND Adsorption. Initially, 2431 references were found, from which 14 were selected to compose the meta-analysis review. With the joint analysis of the data, it was possible to verify using the random model (since the studies assess different contexts) that there is a proportion of effectiveness of the intervention of 81% (with a 95% confidence interval), ranging from 75 to 88%, which is represented by the meta-analysis diamond that is the final result of the statistical analysis. Biochar is effective in removing impurities, even including features such as low cost. There is a considerable lack of studies on the topic of pesticide adsorption with the use of biochar. The studies approach a very heterogeneous perspective on the subject, exposing different contexts.

Keywords: Activated biochar; Adsorption; Effectiveness; Meta-analysis; Pesticides; Systematic review.