Inclusion of key social indices for a comparative assessment of the sustainability of the life cycle of current and future electricity generation in Spain: A proposed methodology

Abstract

The purpose of this work is to offer a methodology for the introduction and consolidation of social indexes within a Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment for the evaluation of large-scale electricity production. This methodology is based on an interrelation of the UNEP subcategories with the global indicator framework for the Sustainable Development Goals, resulting in 9 categories of social impact quantified by 10 indexes. To evaluate the introduction of this methodology in an LCSA a study case is used. It is applied to obtain social indexes for the 2019, 2030 and 2050 Spanish electricity scenarios, which involve different electricity generation and storage technologies: involve coal, natural gas, nuclear, hydropower, wind, solar photovoltaic, concentrated solar, biomass and storage technologies. Within the study case, an environmental life cycle assessment is also conducted, while the impacts of the economic dimension are estimated by the levelized cost of energy. This study reveals that even before important qualitative information is brought to light, as should be done in any decision-making process, there are important gaps that can be filled in terms of quantitative information in an LCSA. To do so, it provides with a methodology to expand the number of social indexes normally used in this type of assessments with the purpose of contributing to decision processes with clarity and transparency. Labour rights, salary differences for the same position, diversity in executive positions, child labour, and R&D expenditure complement the previously used occupational injuries, fatalities due to large accidents, and direct employment. The proposed methodology is applied to a Spanish case study, demonstrating the benefits and disadvantages associated with the modification of the electricity mix. However, it also highlights significant information gaps in availability and transparency that need to be addressed in future research, as part of the path towards standardizing LCSA.

Keywords: Economic life cycle analysis; Electricity production; Life cycle sustainability assessment; Social life cycle assessment; Sustainable development goals.