Examination of the cross-reactivity between vaccinia virus Tiantan strain and monkeypox virus

Abstract

Aim: To investigate the cross-reactivity between the sera collected from Vaccinia Virus Tiantan Strain vaccinated rabbits and viral antigens of monkeypox virus.

Methods: Vaccinia viruses were prepared on chicken embryo fibroblasts (CEF) and Vero cells respectively named as CEF-VTT NVSI-1 and Vero-VTT NVSI-1. Rabbits were inoculated with a total of three doses of adjuvanted 1.3 × 10⁸ PFU CEF-VTT NVSI-1 each dose or adjuvanted 3.9 × 10⁷ PFU Vero-VTT NVSI-1 (Freunds complete adjuvant) via the subcutaneous route. We then performed the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and bio-layer interferometry (BLI) for determination of the binding activity and affinity of immune sera to five crucial surface antigens on monkeypox virus including A35, B6R, H3 and to corresponding homologous antigens A33R, B5 and L1R of vaccinia virus. For comparison, plaque reduction neutralizing tests were used to evaluate the neutralization of immune sera against vaccinia virus.

Results: Both CEF-VTT NVSI-1 and Vero-VTT NVSI-1 vaccinations following planned schedule could induce neutralizing antibody titers greater than 1:2048 in rabbit sera. Binding antibodies targeting monkeypox viral antigens were confirmed by both indirect ELISA and BLI methods. Indirect ELISA for rabbit sera revealed 1:51200 binding antibody titers to A35/B6R/H3 monkeypox virus antigens while BLI tests yielded affinities at 2 × 10^-6 to 8 × 10^-7 between the sera and the three antigens. Similarly, such sera showed binding strength to vaccinia virus antigens A33R/B5/L1R consistent with that to three preceding monkeypox virus antigens. These results demonstrated the cross-reactivity between the sera of vaccinia virus vaccinated animals and monkeypox virus antigens. Traditional ELISA test and BLI method displayed a high consistency in antigen screening and they were further proved to correlate to the results of plaque reduction neutralizing test, which indicates that BLI could be utilized as an indirect alternative for assessment of neutralizing activity of samples in response to live virus.

Conclusions: Sera of vaccinia virus-vaccinated rabbits exhibited cross-reactivity with viral antigens of monkeypox virus. Potential in improving the accuracy of antigen discovery while reducing the lengthy work needed for the screening as BLI method possesses, it contributes greatly to the rapid preliminary evaluation of immune response generated by vaccines.

Keywords: Bio-layer interferometry; Cross-reactivity; Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; Monkeypox virus; Vaccinia virus.