The primary aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of alveolar ridge preservation (ARP) therapy compared with unassisted socket healing (USH) in attenuating interproximal soft tissue atrophy. Adult subjects that underwent maxillary single-tooth extraction with or without ARP therapy were included in this study. Surface scans and cone beam computed tomography were obtained to digitally assess interproximal soft tissue height changes and measure facial bone thickness (FBT), respectively. Logistic regression models were conducted to investigate the individual effect of demographic and clinical variables. Ninety-six subjects (USH=49; ARP=47) constituted the study population. Linear soft tissue assessments revealed a significant reduction of the interproximal soft tissue over time within and between groups (P<.0001). ARP therapy significantly attenuated interproximal soft tissue height reduction compared to USH (USH mesial: -2.0±0.9mm vs. ARP mesial: -1.0±0.5mm / USH distal -1.9±0.7mm vs. ARP distal: -1.1±0.5mm; P<.0001). Thin FBT (≤1mm) upon extraction was associated with greater interproximal soft tissue atrophy compared with thick FBT (>1mm), independently of the treatment received (P<.0001). Nevertheless, ARP therapy resulted in better preservation of interproximal soft tissue height especially in thin bone phenotype by a factor of 2 for the mesial site (+1.3mm) and a factor of 1.6 (+0.9mm) for the distal site. This study demonstrated that ARP therapy largely attenuates interproximal soft tissue dimensional reduction after maxillary single-tooth extraction compared with USH.