Objective: To study the effects of staged Duckett urethroplasty and Byars reconstruction in the treatment of severe hypospadias with dysplastic glans.
Methods: We retrospectively analyzed the clinical data on 57 cases of severe hypospadias with dysplastic glans treated by two-stage Duckett urethroplasty or Byars reconstruction from September 2015 to May 2020. At stage-Ⅰ treatment, the patients were aged from 5 to 47 (mean 21) months, the diameter of the glans less than 1.4 cm, and the interval between the two stages from 6 to 41 (mean 14) months. The patients underwent Duckett urethroplasty, distal in stage Ⅰ and proximal in stage Ⅱ (group A, n = 25) or Byars reconstruction with the urethral plate in stage Ⅰ and Duplay urethroplasty in stage Ⅱ (group B, n = 32). Postoperative follow-up lasted 12－56 (mean 35) months.
Results: After stage Ⅱ surgery, penile straightening and smooth appearance of the graft were achieved in all the patients. Six cases of postoperative complications (24%) were observed in group A, including 4 cases of urinary fistula, 1 case of glans dehiscence, 1 case of urethral diverticulum and 1 case of urethral stricture, while 14 cases (43.8%) were observed in group B, including 9 cases of urinary fistula, 9 cases of glans dehiscence and 2 cases of urethral diverticulum, with a remarkably lower incidence rate of glans dehiscence in group A than in B (P = 0.043), but no statistically significant difference in the other observations between the two groups (P > 0.05).
Conclusion: Both staged strategies of Duckett urethroplasty and Byars reconstruction can be used for the treatment of severe hypospadias with dysplastic glans, but the latter may result in a higher incidence rate of glans dehiscence postoperatively and bring more difficulties to subsequent repair.
Keywords: severe hypospadias; dysplastic glans; staged surgery.