Discovery and Development of the Enantioselective Minisci Reaction

Acc Chem Res. 2023 Jul 18;56(14):2037-2049. doi: 10.1021/acs.accounts.3c00247. Epub 2023 Jul 5.

Abstract

ConspectusThe class of reactions now known as Minisci reactions is broadly defined as the addition of nucleophilic carbon-based radicals to basic heteroarenes with subsequent rearomatization to form a new carbon-carbon bond. Since the pioneering work of Minisci in the 1960s and 1970s, these reactions are now widely used in medicinal chemistry due to the ubiquity of basic heterocycles in druglike molecules. One of the long-standing challenges of Minisci chemistry has been that of regioselectivity due to the mixtures of positional isomers commonly obtained on many substrates if there is a choice between similarly activated sites. At the outset of the work described herein, we hypothesized that it may be possible to tackle this using a catalytic strategy whereby a bifunctional Brønsted acid catalyst simultaneously activates the heteroarene and engages attractive non-covalent interactions with the incoming nucleophile, resulting in a proximal attack. Using chiral BINOL-derived phosphoric acids, we not only were able to achieve this goal of regiocontrol but also discovered that we could control the absolute stereochemistry at the new stereocenter formed when prochiral α-amino radicals were employed. At the time, this discovery was unprecedented in the context of Minisci reactions.This Account details the discovery of this protocol and the further development, expansion, and investigations into the mechanism that we have carried out since then, several in collaboration with other research groups. Collaborative efforts have involved an expansion of the scope to diazines guided by multivariate statistical analysis through the development of a predictive model (collaboration with Sigman). Also, a mechanistic study involving detailed DFT analysis (collaboration with Goodman and Ermanis) unveiled the selectivity-determining step as being the deprotonation of a key cationic radical intermediate by the associated chiral phosphate anion. We have additionally carried out a number of synthetic developments of the protocol such as removing the need to prefunctionalize the radical nucleophile; hydrogen-atom transfer can be used to enable a formal coupling of two C-H bonds to form a C-C bond while retaining high enantio- and regioselectivity. Most recently, we have been able to expand the protocol so that α-hydroxy radicals can be used: until this point, all examples had concerned α-amino radicals. Again, HAT was used to generate the α-hydroxy radicals, and DFT studies carried out in collaboration (Ermanis) provided mechanistic insights.Since our original report, there have appeared a number of exciting developments from other research groups whereby the protocol has been applied to new substrates or using different precursors to generate the requisite α-amino radical. There have also been several examples in which alternative photocatalyst systems have been used to reduce the redox-active esters in the original enantioselective Minisci protocol. While primarily an Account, these contributions from other research groups will be covered briefly for context toward the end of the article.