A benchmark study of convolutional neural networks in fully automatic segmentation of aortic root

Abstract

Recent clinical studies have suggested that introducing 3D patient-specific aortic root models into the pre-operative assessment procedure of transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) would reduce the incident rate of peri-operative complications. Tradition manual segmentation is labor-intensive and low-efficient, which cannot meet the clinical demands of processing large data volumes. Recent developments in machine learning provided a viable way for accurate and efficient medical image segmentation for 3D patient-specific models automatically. This study quantitively evaluated the auto segmentation quality and efficiency of the four popular segmentation-dedicated three-dimensional (3D) convolutional neural network (CNN) architectures, including 3D UNet, VNet, 3D Res-UNet and SegResNet. All the CNNs were implemented in PyTorch platform, and low-dose CTA image sets of 98 anonymized patients were retrospectively selected from the database for training and testing of the CNNs. The results showed that despite all four 3D CNNs having similar recall, Dice similarity coefficient (DSC), and Jaccard index on the segmentation of the aortic root, the Hausdorff distance (HD) of the segmentation results from 3D Res-UNet is 8.56 ± 2.28, which is only 9.8% higher than that of VNet, but 25.5% and 86.4% lower than that of 3D UNet and SegResNet, respectively. In addition, 3D Res-UNet and VNet also performed better in the 3D deviation location of interest analysis focusing on the aortic valve and the bottom of the aortic root. Although 3D Res-UNet and VNet are evenly matched in the aspect of classical segmentation quality evaluation metrics and 3D deviation location of interest analysis, 3D Res-UNet is the most efficient CNN architecture with an average segmentation time of 0.10 ± 0.04 s, which is 91.2%, 95.3% and 64.3% faster than 3D UNet, VNet and SegResNet, respectively. The results from this study suggested that 3D Res-UNet is a suitable candidate for accurate and fast automatic aortic root segmentation for pre-operative assessment of TAVR.

Keywords: 3D CNN; TAVR; aortic root; automatic segmentation; deep learning.