Empirically derived sequence similarity thresholds to study the genomic epidemiology of plasmids shared among healthcare-associated bacterial pathogens

Abstract

Background: Healthcare-associated bacterial pathogens frequently carry plasmids that contribute to antibiotic resistance and virulence. The horizontal transfer of plasmids in healthcare settings has been previously documented, but genomic and epidemiologic methods to study this phenomenon remain underdeveloped. The objectives of this study were to apply whole-genome sequencing to systematically resolve and track plasmids carried by nosocomial pathogens in a single hospital, and to identify epidemiologic links that indicated likely horizontal plasmid transfer.

Methods: We performed an observational study of plasmids circulating among bacterial isolates infecting patients at a large hospital. We first examined plasmids carried by isolates sampled from the same patient over time and isolates that caused clonal outbreaks in the same hospital to develop thresholds with which horizontal plasmid transfer within a tertiary hospital could be inferred. We then applied those sequence similarity thresholds to perform a systematic screen of 3074 genomes of nosocomial bacterial isolates from a single hospital for the presence of 89 plasmids. We also collected and reviewed data from electronic health records for evidence of geotemporal links between patients infected with bacteria encoding plasmids of interest.

Findings: Our analyses determined that 95% of analyzed genomes maintained roughly 95% of their plasmid genetic content and accumulated fewer than 15 SNPs per 100 kb of plasmid sequence. Applying these similarity thresholds to identify horizontal plasmid transfer identified 45 plasmids that potentially circulated among clinical isolates. Ten highly preserved plasmids met criteria for geotemporal links associated with horizontal transfer. Several plasmids with shared backbones also encoded different additional mobile genetic element content, and these elements were variably present among the sampled clinical isolate genomes.

Interpretation: Evidence suggests that the horizontal transfer of plasmids among nosocomial bacterial pathogens appears to be frequent within hospitals and can be monitored with whole genome sequencing and comparative genomics approaches. These approaches should incorporate both nucleotide identity and reference sequence coverage to study the dynamics of plasmid transfer in the hospital.

Funding: This research was supported by the US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease (NIAID) and the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine.

Keywords: Antibiotic resistance; Genomic epidemiology; Horizontal gene transfer; Plasmid.