Although the catalyst-free dynamic thia-Michael (tM) reaction has been leveraged for a range of significant applications in materials science and pharmaceutical development, exploiting its full potential has been limited by relatively low equilibrium constants. To address this shortcoming, a new series of catalyst-free, room-temperature dynamic thia-Michael acceptors bearing an isoxazolone motif were developed and utilized to access both dynamic covalent networks and linear polymers. By leveraging the generation of aromaticity upon thiol addition and tuning the electronic-withdrawing/donating nature of the acceptor at two different sites, a wide range of equilibrium constants (Keq ∼1000 to ∼100,000 M-1) were obtained, constituting a 2 orders of magnitude increase compared to their noncyclic benzalcyanoacetate analogues. Integration into a ditopic isoxazolone-based Michael acceptor allowed access to both bulk dynamic networks and linear polymers; these materials not only exhibited tailorable thermomechanical properties based on thia-Michael acceptor composition, but the higher Keq tM bonds resulted in more mechanically robust materials relative to past designs. Furthermore, solution-state formation of linear polymers was achieved thanks to the increased Keq of the isoxazolone-based acceptors.