Pyrethrins from Tanacetum cinerariifolium are natural pesticides that exhibit high knockdown and killing activities against flying insects such as disease-spreading mosquitoes. Despite the increasing demand for pyrethrins, the mechanism of pyrethrin biosynthesis remains elusive. To elucidate it, we for the first time created pyrethrin mimetic phosphonates targeting the GDSL esterase/lipase (GELP or TcGLIP) underpinning pyrethrin biosynthesis. The compounds were synthesized by reacting mono-alkyl or mono-benzyl-substituted phosphonic dichloride with pyrethrolone, the alcohol moiety of pyrethrin I and II, and then p-nitrophenol. n-Pentyl (C5) and n-octyl (C8)-substituted compounds were the most potent of the (S)p,(S)c, and (R)p,(S)c diastereomers, respectively. The (S)-pyrethrolonyl group is more effective than the (R)-pyrethrolonyl group in blocking TcGLIP, consistent with the features predicted by TcGLIP models complexed with the (S)p,(S)c-C5 and (R)p,(S)c-C8 probes. The (S)p,(S)c-C5 compound suppressed pyrethrin production in T. cinerariifolium, demonstrating potential as a chemical tool for unravelling pyrethrin biosynthesis.