Introduction: Only a few reports have described the clinical features of recurrent spinal cord tumors. This study aimed to report the recurrence rates (RRs), radiographic imaging, and pathological features of various histopathological recurrent spinal cord tumors using a large sample size.
Methods: This study adopted the retrospective observational study design using a single-center study setting. We retrospectively reviewed 818 consecutive individuals operated for spinal cord and cauda equina tumors between 2009 and 2018 in a university hospital. We first determined the number of surgeries and then the histopathology, duration to reoperation, number of surgeries, location, degree of tumor resection, and tumor configuration of the recurrent cases.
Results: A total of 99 patients (46 men and 53 women) who underwent multiple surgeries were identified. The mean duration between the primary and second surgeries was 94.8 months. A total of 74 patients underwent surgery twice, 18 patients thrice, and 7 patients 4 or more times. The recurrence sites were broadly distributed over the spine, with mainly intramedullary (47.5%) and dumbbell-shaped (31.3%) tumors. The RRs for each histopathology were as follows: schwannoma, 6.8%; meningioma and ependymoma, 15.9%; hemangioblastoma, 15.8%; and astrocytoma, 38.9%. The RRs after total resection were significantly lower (4.4%) than that after partial resection. Neurofibromatosis-associated schwannomas had a higher RR than sporadic schwannomas (p<0.001, odds ratio [OR]=8.54, 95% confidence interval [95% CI]: 3.67-19.93). Among the meningiomas, the RR increased to 43.5% in ventral cases (p<0.001, OR=14.36, 95% CI: 3.66-55.29). Within the ependymomas, partial resection (p<0.001, OR=2.871, 95% CI: 1.37-6.03) was found to be significantly correlated with recurrence. Dumbbell-shaped schwannomas exhibited a higher RR than non-dumbbell-shaped ones. Furthermore, dumbbell-shaped tumors other than schwannoma had a higher RR than dumbbell-shaped schwannomas (p<0.001, OR=16.0, 95% CI: 5.518-46.191).
Conclusions: Aiming for total resection is essential to prevent recurrence. Dumbbell-shaped schwannomas and ventral meningiomas exhibited higher RR requiring revision surgery. As for dumbbell-shaped tumors, spinal surgeons should pay attention to the possibilities of non-schwannoma histopathologies.
Keywords: dumbbell-shaped tumor; intramedullary ependymoma; recurrent spinal cord tumor; spinal astrocytoma; ventral meningioma.
Copyright © 2023 The Japanese Society for Spine Surgery and Related Research.