In vitro bioassays to monitor complex chemical mixtures at a carbon-based indirect potable reuse plant

Abstract

Potable water reuse technologies are used to treat wastewater to drinking water quality to help sustain a community's water resources. California has long led the adoption of potable water reuse technologies in the United States and more states are exploring these technologies as water resources decline. Reuse technologies also need to achieve adequate reductions in microbial and chemical contaminant risks to meet public health goals and secure public acceptance. In vitro bioassays are a useful tool for screening if reuse treatment processes adequately reduce toxicity associated with a range of chemical classes that are contaminants of concern. In this study, we used an aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) and an estrogen receptor luciferase bioassay to detect the presence of dioxin-like and estrogenic compounds across a 3800 m³/d carbon-based indirect potable reuse plant that uses carbon-based treatment (SWIFT-RC). Our results demonstrate significant removal of dioxin-like compounds across the SWIFT-RC treatment train. Estrogenicity declined across the treatment train for some months but was extremely variable and low with many samples falling below the method quantification level; consequently, we were not able to reliably determine estrogenicity trends for SWIFT-RC. Comparing the bioanalytical equivalent concentrations detected in the SWIFT-RC water with established monitoring trigger levels from the state of California suggests that SWIFT-RC produced water that met the bioassay guidelines. The log total organic carbon concentration and AhR assay equivalent concentrations are weakly correlated when data across all SWIFT-RC processes are included. Overall, this research demonstrates the performance of in vitro bioassays at a demonstration-scale carbon-based IPR system and highlights both the potential utility and challenges associated with these methods for assessing system performance.