The naturally occurring enediynes are notable for their complex structures, potent DNA cleaving ability, and emerging usefulness in cancer chemotherapy. They can be classified into three distinct structural families, but all are thought to originate from a common linear C15-heptaene. Dynemicin A (DYN) is the paradigm member of anthraquinone-fused enediynes, one of the three main classes and exceptional among them for derivation of both its enediyne and anthraquinone portions from this same early biosynthetic building block. Evidence is growing about how two structurally dissimilar, but biosynthetically related, intermediates combine in two heterodimerization reactions to create a nitrogen-containing C30-coupled product. We report here deletions of two genes that encode biosynthetic proteins that are annotated as S-adenosylmethionine (SAM)-dependent methyltransferases. While one, DynO6, is indeed the required O-methyltransferase implicated long ago in the first studies of DYN biosynthesis, the other, DynA5, functions in an unanticipated manner in the post-heterodimerization events that complete the biosynthesis of DYN. Despite its removal from the genome of Micromonospora chersina, the ΔdynA5 strain retains the ability to synthesize DYN, albeit in reduced titers, accompanied by two unusual co-metabolites. We link the appearance of these unexpected structures to a substantial and contradictory body of other recent experimental data to advance a biogenetic rationale for the downstream steps that lead to the final formation of DYN. A sequence of product-forming transformations that is in line with new and existing experimental results is proposed and supported by a model reaction that also encompasses the formation of the crucial epoxide essential for the activation of DYN for DNA cleavage.