More than two centuries ago, Swiss philosopher I. P. V. Troxler announced in 1804 that fixated images fade away during normal vision. Since this declaration, the phenomenon now known as Troxler fading has become the subject of intensive research. Many researchers were eager to find out why we experience image fading and under what conditions image restoration happens. Here, we investigated the dynamics of color stimulus fading and recovery under sustained eye fixation. The objective of the experiments was to find out which colors fade and recover faster under isoluminant conditions. The stimuli were eight blurred color rings extending to 13° in size. Four unique colors (red, yellow, green, and blue) and four intermediate colors (magenta, cyan, yellow-green, and orange) were used. Stimuli were displayed on a computer monitor with a gray background and were isoluminant to the background. The presentation of the stimulus lasted 2 min and subjects were required to look at the fixation point in the middle of the ring and suppress eye movements. The task for subjects was to report the moments of change in the stimulus visibility by four stages of stimulus completeness. We found that all investigated colors undergo fading and recovery cycles during 2 min of observation. The data suggest that magenta and cyan colors have faster stimulus fading and undergo more recovery cycles, while longer wavelength colors slow down stimulus fading.