Bifurcation behaviors shape how continuous physical dynamics solves discrete Ising optimization

Nat Commun. 2023 May 2;14(1):2510. doi: 10.1038/s41467-023-37695-3.

Abstract

Simulating physical dynamics to solve hard combinatorial optimization has proven effective for medium- to large-scale problems. The dynamics of such systems is continuous, with no guarantee of finding optimal solutions of the original discrete problem. We investigate the open question of when simulated physical solvers solve discrete optimizations correctly, with a focus on coherent Ising machines (CIMs). Having established the existence of an exact mapping between CIM dynamics and discrete Ising optimization, we report two fundamentally distinct bifurcation behaviors of the Ising dynamics at the first bifurcation point: either all nodal states simultaneously deviate from zero (synchronized bifurcation) or undergo a cascade of such deviations (retarded bifurcation). For synchronized bifurcation, we prove that when the nodal states are uniformly bounded away from the origin, they contain sufficient information for exactly solving the Ising problem. When the exact mapping conditions are violated, subsequent bifurcations become necessary and often cause slow convergence. Inspired by those findings, we devise a trapping-and-correction (TAC) technique to accelerate dynamics-based Ising solvers, including CIMs and simulated bifurcation. TAC takes advantage of early bifurcated "trapped nodes" which maintain their sign throughout the Ising dynamics to reduce computation time effectively. Using problem instances from open benchmark and random Ising models, we validate the superior convergence and accuracy of TAC.