Background: Organizational readiness for implementation (ORI) is a barrier to disseminating recovery-oriented evidence-based practices for people with severe mental illnesses. However, there is a knowledge gap regarding implementation strategies and specific actions related to those strategies that may enhance ORI across organizations. The Transtheoretical Model (TTM) is a well-established stage-based model used to support organizational change. In TTM, the first three stages-Pre-contemplation, Contemplation, and Preparation-represent the pre-implementation phase, during which ORI should be developed. This study explored ORI enhancement strategies reported as useful by different stakeholders in the field of community mental health (CMH) and tested the applicability of the TTM readiness stages as an organizing framework to direct ORI development.
Methods: The study included the following two phases: (1) a qualitative exploration of ORI enhancement actions reported by various stakeholders in the CMH field (N = 16) based on their experience in successful implementation projects and (2) a consolidation process performed by the research team to create coherent groups of actions and their overarching implementation strategies per readiness stage.
Results: A comprehensive list of strategies and related actions was created. The strategies and actions correspond with each of the first three stages of the TTM. Stakeholders differed in their methods of facilitating engagement across the organization and in their level of involvement in developing ORI.
Conclusions: This study is a first step in conceptualizing a systematic process for developing ORI using the TTM as a theoretical framework. Future studies should test the transferability and effectiveness of this repository to other implementation efforts, expend the lists per stage, and further explore differences between stakeholders' role in ORI development.
Plain language abstract: Interventions that were proven effective in supporting the recovery of people with mental illnesses are not sufficiently available in the field of community mental health. One barrier to getting those interventions implemented is the lack of willingness and preparedness of organizations to change their practice, also referred to as organizational readiness for implementation (ORI). Little is known about how to enhance ORI to increase the availability of interventions. This study explored actions used to enhance ORI by people in different roles who successfully implemented new recovery-oriented interventions in community mental health settings. The actions were organized into three stages of readiness development based on the Transtheoretical Model (TTM) of behavioral change. Differences were found between administrators, consultants, supervisors, and providers in the type and number of strategies they described. The results show the applicability of the TTM as an organizing framework for ORI development and provide sets of strategies and specific actions to support different readiness needs across the organization.
Keywords: Adoption; Transtheoretical Model; community mental health services; implementation strategy; pre-implementation; qualitative methods; readiness; stages of implementation.
© The Author(s) 2021.